diff --git a/MOBILE_RELAY_EVALUATION.md b/MOBILE_RELAY_EVALUATION.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..93e90eb --- /dev/null +++ b/MOBILE_RELAY_EVALUATION.md @@ -0,0 +1,444 @@ +# Mobile Relay Connection Management Evaluation + +## Current Implementation Analysis + +### ✅ **Strengths - What We're Doing Well** + +#### 1. **Basic Mobile Visibility Handling** +- **Page Visibility API**: Uses `document.visibilitychange` to detect when app goes to background/foreground +- **Network Status Monitoring**: Listens for `online`/`offline` events +- **Health Check Integration**: Performs health checks when page becomes visible + +#### 2. **Automatic Reconnection Logic** +- **Exponential Backoff**: Implements reconnection attempts with delays +- **Max Attempts**: Prevents infinite reconnection loops (max 5 attempts) +- **Health Monitoring**: 30-second intervals for connection health checks + +#### 3. **Connection Pool Management** +- **SimplePool Integration**: Uses `nostr-tools` SimplePool for efficient relay management +- **Priority-based Connection**: Connects to relays in priority order +- **Graceful Degradation**: Continues working with partial relay connections + +### ⚠️ **Areas for Improvement - Mobile-Specific Issues** + +#### 1. **WebSocket Lifecycle Management** +```typescript +// Current implementation in relayHub.ts:424-456 +private setupMobileVisibilityHandling(): void { + if (typeof document !== 'undefined') { + this.mobileVisibilityHandler = () => { + if (document.hidden) { + console.log('Page hidden, maintaining WebSocket connections') + // ❌ PROBLEM: Just logs, doesn't optimize connections + } else { + console.log('Page visible, resuming normal WebSocket activity') + this.performHealthCheck() // ✅ Good: Checks health on resume + } + } + } +} +``` + +**Issues:** +- **No Connection Optimization**: When app goes to background, WebSockets remain fully active +- **Battery Drain**: Maintains all subscriptions and connections in background +- **No Smart Throttling**: Doesn't reduce activity when not visible + +#### 2. **Mobile App State Handling** +- **Missing PWA Support**: No handling for `beforeinstallprompt`, `appinstalled` events +- **No Service Worker Integration**: Missing offline/background sync capabilities +- **Limited Mobile-Specific Events**: Doesn't handle `pagehide`/`pageshow` for better mobile detection + +#### 3. **Connection Resilience** +- **Health Check Limitations**: Current health check only verifies relay presence, not actual WebSocket health +- **No Ping/Pong**: Missing WebSocket-level health verification +- **Subscription Recovery**: Subscriptions aren't automatically restored after reconnection + +## 🔧 **Recommended Improvements** + +### 1. **Enhanced Mobile Visibility Handling** + +```typescript +private setupMobileVisibilityHandling(): void { + if (typeof document !== 'undefined') { + this.mobileVisibilityHandler = () => { + if (document.hidden) { + console.log('Page hidden, optimizing WebSocket connections...') + this.optimizeForBackground() + } else { + console.log('Page visible, restoring full WebSocket activity...') + this.restoreFullActivity() + } + } + + // Add mobile-specific events + document.addEventListener('visibilitychange', this.mobileVisibilityHandler) + window.addEventListener('pagehide', this.handlePageHide) + window.addEventListener('pageshow', this.handlePageShow) + } + + // Handle network changes + if (typeof window !== 'undefined') { + window.addEventListener('online', this.handleNetworkOnline) + window.addEventListener('offline', this.handleNetworkOffline) + + // Add connection quality monitoring + if ('connection' in navigator) { + navigator.connection?.addEventListener('change', this.handleConnectionChange) + } + } +} + +private optimizeForBackground(): void { + // Reduce WebSocket activity in background + this.backgroundMode = true + + // Keep only essential connections + this.maintainEssentialConnections() + + // Reduce health check frequency + this.adjustHealthCheckInterval(60000) // 1 minute instead of 30 seconds + + // Suspend non-critical subscriptions + this.suspendNonCriticalSubscriptions() +} + +private restoreFullActivity(): void { + this.backgroundMode = false + + // Restore all connections + this.restoreAllConnections() + + // Resume normal health check frequency + this.adjustHealthCheckInterval(30000) + + // Restore all subscriptions + this.restoreAllSubscriptions() + + // Perform immediate health check + this.performHealthCheck() +} +``` + +### 2. **Smart Connection Management** + +```typescript +interface ConnectionStrategy { + mode: 'foreground' | 'background' | 'critical' + maxConnections: number + healthCheckInterval: number + subscriptionLimit: number +} + +private connectionStrategies: Map = new Map([ + ['foreground', { mode: 'foreground', maxConnections: 5, healthCheckInterval: 30000, subscriptionLimit: 20 }], + ['background', { mode: 'background', maxConnections: 2, healthCheckInterval: 60000, subscriptionLimit: 5 }], + ['critical', { mode: 'critical', maxConnections: 1, healthCheckInterval: 120000, subscriptionLimit: 2 }] +]) + +private maintainEssentialConnections(): void { + const strategy = this.connectionStrategies.get('background')! + + // Keep only the most reliable relays + const essentialRelays = this.getMostReliableRelays(strategy.maxConnections) + + // Disconnect from non-essential relays + this.disconnectNonEssentialRelays(essentialRelays) + + // Maintain only critical subscriptions + this.maintainCriticalSubscriptions(strategy.subscriptionLimit) +} +``` + +### 3. **Enhanced Health Checking** + +```typescript +private async performHealthCheck(): Promise { + if (!this._isConnected) return + + console.log('Performing enhanced relay health check...') + const disconnectedRelays: string[] = [] + const unhealthyRelays: string[] = [] + + for (const [url, relay] of this.connectedRelays) { + try { + // Test actual WebSocket health with ping/pong + const isHealthy = await this.testRelayHealth(relay) + + if (!isHealthy) { + unhealthyRelays.push(url) + } + + // Update relay status + this.updateRelayStatus(url, { + lastSeen: Date.now(), + latency: await this.measureRelayLatency(relay) + }) + + } catch (error) { + console.warn(`Health check failed for relay ${url}:`, error) + disconnectedRelays.push(url) + } + } + + // Handle unhealthy relays + unhealthyRelays.forEach(url => { + console.log(`Relay ${url} is unhealthy, attempting reconnection...`) + this.reconnectRelay(url) + }) + + // Handle disconnected relays + this.handleDisconnectedRelays(disconnectedRelays) +} + +private async testRelayHealth(relay: Relay): Promise { + try { + // Send a ping event to test WebSocket health + const pingEvent = { kind: 1, content: 'ping', created_at: Math.floor(Date.now() / 1000) } + await relay.send(pingEvent) + + // Wait for response or timeout + return new Promise((resolve) => { + const timeout = setTimeout(() => resolve(false), 5000) + + const onMessage = (event: any) => { + if (event.kind === 1 && event.content === 'pong') { + clearTimeout(timeout) + relay.off('message', onMessage) + resolve(true) + } + } + + relay.on('message', onMessage) + }) + } catch (error) { + return false + } +} +``` + +### 4. **Subscription Recovery System** + +```typescript +interface SubscriptionState { + id: string + filters: Filter[] + relays?: string[] + onEvent?: (event: Event) => void + onEose?: () => void + onClose?: () => void + isActive: boolean + lastActivity: number +} + +private subscriptionStates: Map = new Map() + +subscribe(config: SubscriptionConfig): () => void { + // Store subscription state for recovery + this.subscriptionStates.set(config.id, { + ...config, + isActive: true, + lastActivity: Date.now() + }) + + // Perform actual subscription + const unsubscribe = this.performSubscription(config) + + return () => { + this.subscriptionStates.get(config.id)!.isActive = false + unsubscribe() + } +} + +private restoreAllSubscriptions(): void { + console.log('Restoring all subscriptions...') + + for (const [id, state] of this.subscriptionStates) { + if (state.isActive) { + console.log(`Restoring subscription: ${id}`) + this.performSubscription(state) + } + } +} +``` + +### 5. **Mobile-Specific Event Handling** + +```typescript +private handlePageHide = (event: PageTransitionEvent): void => { + // Handle mobile app backgrounding + if (event.persisted) { + console.log('Page is being cached (mobile background)') + this.optimizeForBackground() + } else { + console.log('Page is being unloaded') + this.prepareForUnload() + } +} + +private handlePageShow = (event: PageTransitionEvent): void => { + console.log('Page is being shown (mobile foreground)') + + // Check if we need to reconnect + if (!this._isConnected) { + console.log('Reconnecting after page show...') + this.connect() + } else { + this.restoreFullActivity() + } +} + +private handleConnectionChange = (event: Event): void => { + const connection = (event.target as any) as NetworkInformation + + console.log(`Connection type changed: ${connection.effectiveType}`) + + // Adjust connection strategy based on network quality + if (connection.effectiveType === 'slow-2g' || connection.effectiveType === '2g') { + this.setConnectionStrategy('critical') + } else if (connection.effectiveType === '3g') { + this.setConnectionStrategy('background') + } else { + this.setConnectionStrategy('foreground') + } +} +``` + +## 📱 **Mobile-Specific Best Practices Implementation** + +### 1. **Battery-Aware Connection Management** + +```typescript +private isLowBattery = false + +private setupBatteryMonitoring(): void { + if ('getBattery' in navigator) { + navigator.getBattery().then(battery => { + battery.addEventListener('levelchange', () => { + this.isLowBattery = battery.level < 0.2 + this.adjustConnectionStrategy() + }) + + battery.addEventListener('chargingchange', () => { + this.adjustConnectionStrategy() + }) + }) + } +} + +private adjustConnectionStrategy(): void { + if (this.isLowBattery && !this.isCharging) { + this.setConnectionStrategy('critical') + } else { + this.setConnectionStrategy(this.backgroundMode ? 'background' : 'foreground') + } +} +``` + +### 2. **Progressive Web App Support** + +```typescript +private setupPWASupport(): void { + // Handle app installation + window.addEventListener('beforeinstallprompt', (event) => { + console.log('App can be installed') + this.installPrompt = event + }) + + // Handle app installation completion + window.addEventListener('appinstalled', () => { + console.log('App was installed') + this.isInstalled = true + }) + + // Handle app launch from installed state + if (window.matchMedia('(display-mode: standalone)').matches) { + console.log('App is running in standalone mode') + this.isStandalone = true + } +} +``` + +### 3. **Service Worker Integration** + +```typescript +// In service worker +self.addEventListener('sync', (event) => { + if (event.tag === 'relay-reconnect') { + event.waitUntil(reconnectToRelays()) + } +}) + +// In relay hub +private scheduleBackgroundReconnect(): void { + if ('serviceWorker' in navigator && 'sync' in window.ServiceWorkerRegistration.prototype) { + navigator.serviceWorker.ready.then(registration => { + registration.sync.register('relay-reconnect') + }) + } +} +``` + +## 🧪 **Testing Recommendations** + +### 1. **Mobile Device Testing** +- Test on actual iOS/Android devices +- Test background/foreground transitions +- Test network switching (WiFi ↔ Cellular) +- Test low battery scenarios + +### 2. **Simulation Testing** +```typescript +// Test visibility changes +document.dispatchEvent(new Event('visibilitychange')) + +// Test network changes +window.dispatchEvent(new Event('offline')) +window.dispatchEvent(new Event('online')) + +// Test page transitions +window.dispatchEvent(new PageTransitionEvent('pagehide', { persisted: true })) +window.dispatchEvent(new PageTransitionEvent('pageshow', { persisted: false })) +``` + +### 3. **Performance Monitoring** +```typescript +// Monitor connection efficiency +const connectionMetrics = { + connectionAttempts: 0, + successfulConnections: 0, + failedConnections: 0, + averageLatency: 0, + batteryImpact: 'low' // 'low' | 'medium' | 'high' +} +``` + +## 📊 **Current Implementation Score** + +| Category | Score | Notes | +|----------|-------|-------| +| **Basic Mobile Support** | 6/10 | Has visibility API but limited optimization | +| **Connection Resilience** | 7/10 | Good reconnection logic, needs better health checks | +| **Battery Optimization** | 3/10 | No battery-aware connection management | +| **Network Adaptation** | 5/10 | Basic online/offline handling | +| **Subscription Recovery** | 4/10 | Subscriptions lost on reconnection | +| **Mobile-Specific Events** | 4/10 | Missing key mobile lifecycle events | + +**Overall Score: 4.8/10** + +## 🎯 **Priority Implementation Order** + +1. **High Priority**: Enhanced health checking and subscription recovery +2. **Medium Priority**: Smart background/foreground connection management +3. **Low Priority**: Battery monitoring and PWA support + +## 🚀 **Next Steps** + +1. Implement enhanced health checking with ping/pong +2. Add subscription state persistence and recovery +3. Implement smart connection optimization for background mode +4. Add mobile-specific event handling +5. Test thoroughly on mobile devices +6. Monitor battery impact and connection efficiency + +The current implementation provides a solid foundation but needs significant enhancement to meet mobile best practices for WebSocket management, battery optimization, and connection resilience.